Category Archives: Apologetics

Forgery and Counterforgery, by Bart Ehrman. A Multi-Part Review

Is it possible that some of the books found in our Bible were actually literary forgeries, deceptively written books snuck into the canon of Scripture, unbeknownst to unsuspecting leaders in the early church?

Understandably, most Christians shrink back in horror or disbelief at the very thought, as such a suggestion might shake their faith in the trustworthiness of Scripture. If such an accusation were true, the consequences for the Christian faith would be significant. Nevertheless, a number of critical scholars today have been exploring that very question, a question that has consumed a lot of ink since the days of the 18th century Enlightenment.

Bart Ehrman’s Forgery and Counterforgery: The Use of Literary Deceit in Early Christian Polemics argues that up to 70% of the New Testament material is made up of forged documents. How well do the claims of Bart Ehrman stand up to scrutiny?

 

Is the “Historical Criticism” of the New Testament a Threat to Christianity?

About seven years ago, I partnered in a discussion with one of my pastors, Hunter Ruch, in front of our congregation, to answer the specific objection raised by critics that the Apostle Paul never wrote 2 Timothy.  2 Timothy 3:16 has a very well known verse of the Bible which I memorized years ago, “All Scripture is inspired by God and is profitable for teaching, for rebuking, for correcting, for training in righteousness (CSB).” The video itself is no longer available, but my aim in that discussion was so that our confidence in the integrity of Scripture might be affirmed.

But not everyone received it that way. After the service, one very distraught gentleman confronted me and asked why I even bothered raising the topic in a church worship service. In his mind, this gentleman believed that we should simply take the Bible for what it says to be true, and that should be the end of it. A full consideration of the evidence was a waste of time.

Apparently, this gentleman did not see the value in studying Christian apologetics. He was also unaware of what is being taught in hundreds of religion departments in secular, and even some Christian universities, to thousands of students on a yearly basis.

His advice to me also indicated that he was unfamiliar with something called “social media,” through Tik-Tok and YouTube Short videos. This gentleman was clearly old enough to have teenage children, and yet as he walked away from me I kept wondering if his child possessed a smartphone with ready access to an Instagram or Facebook account.

The following 2-minute YouTube video was recorded by a credentialed, skeptic-leaning biblical scholar, Dan McClellan, just a few thumb clicks away from any smartphone in the hands of a teenager. How would you respond to this?

The onslaught of skepticism about Christianity in the age of the Internet is relentless. Granted, parents or anyone else can feel overwhelmed when faced with these challenges which seem almost endless. However, there are some basic-level apologetic tools available that can assist believers in having greater confidence in their faith.

Daniel McClellan is an accomplished scholar in the area of “historical criticism,” with some helpful videos, addressing dubious claims in popular preaching today, as well as exposing complete nonsense. But a number of Dr. McClellan’s other claims deserve better scrutiny. Several things that are said here in the particular video shown above are contentious, and a couple of them are worth commenting on.

Dr. McClellan’s second point can be addressed first: Dr. McClellan makes the assertion that Paul could not have authored 2 Timothy because it was written decades after his death.This raises the whole spectre of forgery as to what we find in our Bibles, which will be the subject of this and subsequent blog posts in this series.

On the first point in the video, when many Christians read 2 Timothy 3:16 talking about “all Scripture is breathed out by God,” they often think this is a reference to the Bible as we have it now, the Old Testament and all 27 books of the New Testaments combined. However, Daniel McClellan is mainly right here. With respect to the Old Testament, the Jewish community in the time of Paul was not entirely in agreement with what constituted the boundary for the Old Testament writings. While the 39 books within the Protestant canon of the Old Testament were well established, a debate continued for perhaps another several hundred years or so as to whether or not there were more books within that canon of Old Testament texts. Protestant Christians typically associate these debated extra books with the “Apocrypha.”

Regarding the New Testament,  even if you take a very conservative view as to the dating of when 2 Timothy was written, it probably could not have meant to include the whole of the New Testament as “Scripture” as we know it today, as the letters of Paul are generally considered to be the earliest writings found in our New Testament. For example, it is difficult to conceive how Paul might have had the Gospel of John included in his mind as “Scripture,” if it had not been written yet!

Most Christians today retrospectively conclude that 2 Timothy 3:16 can now be taken to mean not just the Old Testament writings as “Scripture,” but the entire collection of New Testament writings as well. Yet this raises the question as to how all the books of the New Testament eventually became regarded as “Scripture,” which theologians define as the development of the “canon” of Scripture or “rule or faith,” long after 2 Timothy was originally penned.

A knee-jerk reaction to Dr. McClellan might be tempting, but he does raise some important questions.

The Development of the New Testament Canon

So, how did we get the exact books which make up our New Testament? An often related question gets asked a lot: “Who chose the books of the New Testament canon?”

It is an understandable question, but it is also a misleading one. Dr. Michael Kruger, the president of Reformed Theological Seminary in Charlotte, North Carolina, suggests that the idea of who “chose” the books of the New Testament canon “conjures images of some meeting, or council, where people voted on books—some books making the cut, and others left out.” But this simply is not the case. The historical record shows a much more organic process to the development of the canon of Scripture:

“If you had lived in the second century and asked the average Christian on the street, ‘Why did you guys pick Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John?,’ I think you would have received some very strange looks. Indeed, I don’t think the question would have made any sense to the average Christian. They didn’t view themselves as choosing anything……”

“….. asking Christians why they chose the Gospels would be akin to asking someone why they chose their parents. No one chooses their parents. They were just kind of ‘there’ from as far back as they can remember.”1

Nevertheless, some people still have questions. I remember a high school friend of mine telling me when he realized that as a young teenager, his parents were not his “real” parents. Instead, he learned that he was adopted at a very young age. It was quite upsetting for him to hear this truth. But it did make me wonder about my own history. When I asked my mom about it, she pulled out a copy of my birth certificate, and that pretty much settled the matter right then and there. All it took was some direct evidence to answer my question.

What evidence then do we have for the New Testament?

Codex Sinaiticus, one of the earliest copies of the Bible, including the New Testament.  But how much of it was written by the people who claimed to have written it?  (credit: bible archaeology.org)

 

Bart Ehrman and the Issue of Forgeries(???)  in Early Christianity

University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, professor Bart Ehrman, who is a professional skeptical scholar like Dan McClellan in the above video, is considered to be one of the most well-known critics of historically orthodox Christianity. In 2011, Ehrman published Forged: Writing in the Name of God — Why the Bible’s Authors Are Not Who We Think They Are, a book written for a popular audience that addresses the problems associated with the canon of the New Testament. Ehman claims that between 8 and 11 of the 27 books of Christian New Testament were written as “forgeries.” This would include the longest book of the New Testament, the Book of Acts, effectively saying that up to 70% of the New Testament is made up of forged documents.

This is a startling claim for Christians unfamiliar with the modern discipline of New Testament studies, as taught in hundreds and hundreds of universities today. However, anyone studying religion at the college level will probably hear such a claim being made in the classroom. Some variation of this claim has been promoted in academia for roughly 200 years, going back at least to the time of the early 19th century German biblical scholar, Ferdinand Christian Baur. The ubiquitous character of social media in the early first quarter of the 21st century only makes such challenges ever ready and accessible to the modern smartphone user. Even more disturbing, such ideas have even found their way into the church, through the door of “progressive Christianity.”2

Bart Ehrman is a New York Times bestselling author, having published over a dozen books like this which challenge historic, orthodox Christian views of the Bible. His videos on YouTube regularly receive each thousands of views, driven mainly by an audience with a skeptical outlook upon the Bible and rejection of conservative evangelical Christian faith. His Misquoting Jesus YouTube podcast, launched just a year ago, has already received well over a million views on social media.

Despite significant disagreements between scholars like Erhman and conservative evangelical scholars, both Erhman and conservative evangelical scholars reject the misguided notion of so-called “Jesus Mythicism,” an avant garde intellectual movement popular in certain atheistic circles which denies the existence of Jesus of Nazareth as an historical figure. Disagreeable as Dr. Ehrman will sound among conservative Christians, Bart Ehrman is not an extremist. With this background in mind, it is important for Christians to understand the types of arguments which Dr. Ehrman brings to the table. Interestingly, long before Bart Ehrman became a household name in the secular media, the Dr. Kruger mentioned above had Bart Ehrman as a religion professor when Kruger was an undergraduate student at Chapel Hill.

In 2012, Ehrman wrote a more academic treatment of the same topic of New Testament origins, Forgery and Counterforgery: The Use of Literary Deceit in Early Christian Polemics., which is the subject of this book review. My aim is to offer an analysis of Ehrman’s primary claims, and address these issues of the canon of the New Testament and its integrity from an historically orthodox Christian perspective.

Last year, I read Bart Ehrman’s popular level book addressing the issues regarding the afterlife in the Bible, Heaven and Hell: A History of the Afterlife. In that Veracity book review, I identified several presuppositions which undergird Dr. Ehrman’s approach to these topics, framing his overall mode of analysis, and guiding him towards his conclusions. I would urge readers to review that blog post as that will aid the reader to understand the big ideas that Bart Ehrman brings to the table, ideas which also undergird his arguments as found in Forgery and Counterforgery. While it is too much to go into here about where Ehrman gets these from, the two primary presuppositions summarized are:

(1) The Bible is inherently a collection of writings which possess a wide range of differences in these texts. However, not only can these differences not be reconciled with one another, the student of the Bible should not try to harmonize such differences as such harmonizations essentially alter and obscure the true meaning associated with these texts. This inherent contradictory nature of the Bible stems from the fundamental diversity present in the Christian movement from the very beginning of Christianity. This essential and irreconcilable diversity is supported by a thesis proposed by an early 20th century German Bible scholar, Walter Bauer.3

(2) Jesus was a failed apocalyptic prophet. He predicted that a great, cataclysmic end of the world would happen within his generation, but that Jesus’ prediction failed to materialize. The shape and character of our New Testament, as well as that of Christianity more broadly, grew out of the Christian movement’s attempt to rethink the teachings of Jesus, in view of this failure of prophecy. This understanding of the apocalyptic character of Christianity was popularized by the famous early 20th century Bible scholar, Albert Schweitzer.

 

If you are looking for Bart Ehrman’s quick “hot take” on these points, here are a couple of YouTube “shorts,” videos that rarely last more than 1 minute each, which briefly summarize the key elements to these two ideas which undergird Ehrman’s work.  The first video is a quick summary of the Walter Bauer thesis, namely that Christianity was highly diverse, even more-so than what we find in Christianity today, right from the very beginning. The second video argues that the three earlier Gospels: Matthew, Mark, and Luke, has Jesus predicting a great, catalclysmic end of the world happening within a generation of Christ’s earliest disciples, as argued by Albert Schweitzer, whereas this apocalyptic message essentially disappears in the Gospel of John, which is generally thought to have been written last, perhaps towards the end of the first century. The implication drawn from this suggests that the great cataclysmic apocalyptic event which Jesus predicted never materialized:

A Thumbnail Sketch of the Walter Bauer Thesis

 

A Thumbnail Sketch of the Albert Schweitzer Thesis

 

Both of these governing ideas drive the argumentation which Dr. Ehrman presents in Forgery and Counterforgery. That being said, there are elements of Bart Ehrman’s thesis which deserve careful consideration. Despite my disagreements with Dr. Ehrman, he is nevertheless a very accomplished, world-class scholar, an excellent communicator, and he comes across to me as quite likable in his interviews.

So, I want to try to interact with Dr. Ehrman’s book both fairly and generously, as much as possible. Due to the length of the book, over 600 written pages, which I listened to for nearly 26 hours through an Audible audiobook, this book review will be split up over multiple blog posts, each with a central nugget of digestible thought. I will not even try to critique everything Bart Ehrman says, since that would probably end up being another big book in and of itself!

This first post will be introductory in nature, discussing some of the fundamental ideas in Ehrman’s book, focusing mainly on the difficulty in defining what is a “forgery.” For some readers, this blog post will be sufficient to offer a rough outline of a response to Forgery and Counterforgery.

In the second blog post, we will examine some of the specific arguments used by Ehrman which attempt to demonstrate that forgeries exist within our New Testament. Reading this will give you a flavor of the method Ehrman uses to draw his conclusions.

The third blog post will examine the particular issues associated with the most controversial of the Pauline letters, what is known to be the “pastoral letters,”  1 Timothy, 2 Timothy, and Titus. I will also show how some “progressive Christian” scholars echo some of the same arguments advanced by Dr. Ehrman.

In the fourth blog post, we will consider the concept of allonymity, used by some conservative evangelical scholars to explain how certain pseudepigraphical writings in our New Testament can still be accepted as being authoritative, without succumbing to the negative assessment associated with the category of “forgery.”

In the fifth and last blog post, we will engage in a thought experiment: What if Bart Ehrman is correct about forgeries in our New Testament? What would be the consequences to Christian faith if a number of Ehrman’s arguments proved to be correct? At the end of that post, I will offer a summary response to Forgery and Counterforgery.

Bart Ehrman, yyy

Bart Ehrman (Agnostic critic of the Bible)

 

What is the Definition of “Forgery?”

What is a “forgery?” The definition of “forgery” is a crucial question to address at the outset. A basic definition which Bart Ehrman uses is “a book written with a false authorial claim.” Some object to the use of the term “forgery,” in that it has negative connotations. Some prefer a more neutral, if not obfuscated word to use, such as “pseudepigraphy,” or “pseudonymous.”

A “pseudonymous” writing can have a broad range of meaning associated with it, where such a work may not necessarily suggest morally objectionable intent. For example, consider the use of pen names. Samuel Clemens famously used the pen name “Mark Twain” to sign his literary work, and yet lovers of great literature see the use of a pen name here more in a benign sense, as opposed to a purely deceptive sense. Some associate the concept of “ghostwriting” with this concept of a more benign sense of pseudonymity, whereby a well-known author hires another writer to produce written material which matches the content, and even the vocabulary and style of the well-known author, with the full acknowledgement and permission of that well-known author. Several contemporary and famous Christians authors, including the late Billy Graham and the late Tim LaHaye, have made use of ghostwriters in their many written works. In contrast with these more benign type of writings, Ehrman links his use of the term “forgery” to a more specific sense of pseudonymity, that of “pseudepigraphy,” whereby “a book appears under the name of a well-known person who did not, in fact, write it.”4

The term “counter-forgery” is related to “forgery,” as Ehrman uses it. A “counter-forgery” acts a forged document written as a polemic against another forged document.

Other scholars will challenge Ehrman’s strict, if not completely synonymous link between “forgery” and “pseudepigraphy.” For example, the well-regarded conservative evangelical scholar, D. A. Carson argues:

A literary forgery is a work written or modified with the intent to deceive. All literary forgeries are pseudepigraphical, but not all pseudepigrapha are literary forgeries. There is a substantial class of pseudepigraphical writings that, in the course of their transmission, somehow became associated with some figure or other. These connections between a text and an ancient figure, however fallacious, were judgments made with the best will in the world.5

The late Old Testament and conservative evangelical scholar, Michael Heiser, offers several examples of pseudepigraphy in the Old Testament, whereby a particular name was attached to a book, despite the fact that no “no evidence exists that their namesake did any of the writing.” Such books include Job, 1 and 2 Samuel, and Joshua. Even though the Book of Joshua became associated with the name of the great military leader and successor to Moses, there is no sense of deceit involved. Technically, the Book of Joshua is pseudonymous, in that Joshua did not himself write the book, but there is no indication that ascribing Joshua’s name to the book was meant to deceive.6

Even in the New Testament, we have evidence that certain New Testament books quote from other pseudepigraphical works. In particular, the Book of Enoch, is both quoted and alluded to in Jude and Peter. Early church fathers praised much of the theology as found in the Book of Enoch, while still acknowledging that Enoch could not have possibly written that book itself, even though the name of Enoch is attached to it.7

Likewise, the conservative evangelical and New Testament scholar, Ben Witherington clarifies the distinction between a falsely written versus a genuine letter of the New Testament:

“The real dividing line between a genuine letter and a pseudepigraphon is whether the material comes from the mind of particular person, not whether it fully reflects that person’s grammar and syntax and vocabulary. To this I would add that a genuine letter comes not only from the mind, but also from the hand, of the author, or is inscribed upon the author’s request or behalf.”8

Witherington’s point is that in an age where the art of writing was more of a professional endeavor, when papyrus was less flexible than the use of modern paper, and illiteracy in the Greco-Roman world was very high, the use of secretaries to produce literary work was actually quite common. Authors could give their professional scribes great leeway in their writing, which can account for variances in grammar, syntax, and vocabulary. In other words, an author could “authorize” a secretary to express their ideas in a manner more fitting to the purposes at hand.

Do we have forgeries in our New Testament? Veracity investigates the claims found in Bart Ehrman’s Forgery and Counterforgery: The Use of Literary Deceit in Early Christian Polemics.

 

“Pseudepigraphy” versus “Forgery:” What is the Difference?

It would therefore appear that the definition of pseudepigraphy is the subject of some dispute, as there are cases where such a possible work might have certain suspicions surrounding it, while still being held in high esteem in the Bible, depending on the circumstances. So, are there other cases where an alignment between “pseudepigraphy” and “forgery” are less clear?

For example, there are no known New Testament scholars, conservative or liberal, who dispute that Paul wrote the Book of Romans. Nevertheless, Romans 16:22 explicitly states that “I, Tertius, wrote this letter.” Clearly, Tertius was Paul’s secretary but he was writing under the full supervision of the great Apostle.

Bart Ehrman disputes the claim that the use of secretaries among ancient writers accounts for variations of style and vocabulary as supposed by evangelical Christian apologists, who seek to defend the inspiration of Scripture. But he also acknowledges that in and of themselves, literary style and vocabulary alone is insufficient to fully demonstrate that any particular writing is a forgery. What ultimately matters is the actual content and message of the literary work itself.

The problem is complicated by the fact that there are books in our Bible which lack a clear, undisputed author standing behind the work. The classic New Testament example of this is the Book of Hebrews. One will search the pages of Hebrews looking for the name of the author, but this is nowhere to be found. Some have claimed that Paul wrote Hebrews, while others say Luke wrote it, and some have speculated that a woman, Priscilla, wrote it. We may never know on this side of history who was the genuine author of Hebrews.

Nevertheless, the lack of a clear authorial attribution for Hebrews did not deter the early church from recognizing the book’s apostolic authority and authenticity. It was sufficient enough for the early church to acknowledge that an inspired New Testament book must have been written either by a well-known apostle, such as Paul or Peter, who is claimed to have had a particularly close, earthly encounter with Jesus, either before and/or after the Resurrection of Jesus. Or the early church also acknowledged writings from someone who traveled within that early apostolic circle, such as Luke.

Luke never had a close, earthly encounter with Jesus. But he was a well known traveling companion with Paul. Furthemore, for the early church fathers, the content of any authentic New Testament writing must have been theologically in tune with those early teachings of Jesus and his disciples. This theological consistency and coherency was known as “the rule of faith.” Therefore, even though Hebrews lacked a definitive authorial designation, the theology articulated in that letter was acknowledged to be fully inline with “the rule of faith,” as preached by the early church.

However, how did the early church know if a particular book met such qualifications of authenticity? Is it possible for a deceptively pseudonymous writing of some sort to have been accepted anyway into the New Testament?

Christian Use of the “Noble Lie”

Some speak of the concept of a “noble lie” as a justification for some types of pseudonymous writings, or certain speech acts in general. The Bible famously includes as one of the Ten Commandments the command to not “bear false witness against one’s neighbor.” Telling the truth is an essential moral rule which the Bible unequivocally elevates as being most important. At the same time, we read of the story of Rahab, the prostitute in Jericho, who famously lied to her fellow Canaanites, telling them that the Hebrew spies hiding in her house had already fled the town (Joshua 2). In acknowledgement of this deceitful bravery, which would have cost her life, not to mention the lives of the Hebrew spies she was protecting, if her lie had been discovered, she was nevertheless recognized and celebrated in Jesus’ genealogy (Matthew 1:5).

Jerome, an early church father and the great translator of the Latin Vulgate, believed that in Galatians 2:11-14, when Paul rebuked Peter publicly for not eating with Gentile believers, that this incident was actually a version of the “noble lie.” Ehrman writes about this:

In Jerome’s well-known position, Peter and Paul did not actually have a falling out. They put on a show, in a double act of dissimulation: Peter “pretended” to be subject to Jewish dietary laws for the sake of the brethren, knowing that he was not really subject to them, and Paul, cognizant of the true state of things, “pretended” to rebuke Peter in order to show the gentile Christians that he was on their side so as to keep from giving offense. (Ehrman, p. 453).

Saint Augustine, a contemporary of Jerome’s, was not impressed by Jerome’s interpretation of Galatians 2, as Augustine was known to be skeptical of the concept of the “noble lie.” Nevertheless, other examples of such lying are recorded in Scripture, where those who were in on the lie were celebrated for their actions.The Hebrew midwives lied to Pharaoh, and protected the lives of baby Hebrew boys, and the Bible honors them in their bravery through the telling of their lie (Exodus 1:15-22). Michal, David’s wife, lied to David’s pursuers, thus saving the life of the future king (1 Samuel 19:11-18).

While some Christians like Augustine balk at the use of the “noble lie,” other Christians have defended its use and honor those who participate in such deceptions. Ehrman even acknowledges that another well-regarded church father contemporaneous to Augustine, John Cassian, disputed Augustine’s rigid view against the “noble lie,” suggesting that even the Bible, as in the case of Rehab lying to protect Hebrew spies, approves of it (Ehrman, p. 538-539).

In more recent times, Corrie ten Boom, in her classic work The Hiding Place, tells about deceiving the Nazi’s who occupied her Dutch town by offering sanctuary to hundreds of Jews fleeing Nazi oppression. Countless other Christians during the Nazi era did the same, saving the lives of many, many Jews. Numerous Christians in the armed forces during periods of war have participated in espionage activities, thus deceiving their enemies, earning accolades from fellow Christians for these acts of bravery. The well-known and highly respected theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer participated in a plot to assassinate Adolph Hitler, and was eventually arrested and executed for his deceptive acts.

Imagine you were a Christian living in Nazi-held Europe in the 1940s, and some Jews were seeking refuge from the Nazis, and you put them up for the night in your home. The next day, the Gestapo knocks on the door and asks, “Are there any Jews in your house?”

Would you really respond with something like this?: “Why, yes. There are Jews here. Since I am a Christian, and Christians are not supposed to lie because of the Ninth Commandment, I am compelled to tell you that the Jews are down the hallway on the right. Not the first door on the right, but the second door on the right. If you look over this way, you can see them climbing out of the window right now. If you act quickly, Mr. Gestapo-person, you might still have time to catch them. In giving you all of this information, I now feel satisfied and self-vindicated that I have kept God’s commandment not to lie.”

Hopefully, the absurdity of such a response is apparent. If a Christian quarterback on a football team were to throw a no-look pass, would he need to repent of his deceptive “sin” after the game?

Again, it should be evident that not everything that falls under the category of “deception” would be a violation of the Ninth Commandment. As the late Dr. Michael Heiser has written,

“The command ‘thou shalt not bear false witness’ refers to uttering words, and, in context, in a courtroom setting (the biblical ‘by two or three witnesses things will be known’ idea). …..Undoing or forbidding acts of heroism and courtesy is NOT the purpose of the ninth command. The command was not given to allow evil to proliferate, to have others suffer, to have children lose innocence, or to compel people to be rude.”

True, such an exception could easily be misused to justify the actual sin of bearing false witness against one’s neighbor. Delilah badgered Samson to reveal the truth about the source of his strength, and then deceived Samson by using that knowledge to betray Samson to the Philistines (Judges 16:19).

We should also remember that Ananias and Sapphira deceptively hid the fact that they withheld part of the proceeds of the sale of some property from the church, an example of bearing false witness which resulted in their immediate deaths (Acts 5:1-11). God takes truth-telling seriously. So, it does raise a good question as to when such deception fits into some category, like the “noble lie,” versus an act of deception intent on distorting the truth for self-gain, or some other corrupt motivation. Where is the line between the two?

A good argument can therefore be made to suggest that given the right circumstances, a type of pseudonymous writing might have made its way into the canon of Scripture, under the full inspiration of the Holy Spirit. Here is similar example: For if we have purposely fictitious stories called “parables,” which Jesus used as teaching tools in the Gospels, it would be difficult to completely rule out all fiction in the Bible as being inherently contradictory with the notion of Scriptural inspiration.

On the other hand, there are other cases where the presence of pseudepigraphy within the canon of Scripture would be disastrous for our understanding of the integrity of the Bible. For if an unscrupulous author were able to fake their identity in their written work, taking upon themselves the false claim of being Paul or Peter, for the purpose of misleading their readers, in order to promote an agenda contrary to that of the original apostles, then such pseudepigraphy would compromise our confidence in the Bible as truly being the Word of God. Therefore, discerning the difference between these two categories is essential.

A fragment of the Gospel of Peter found at Akhmim, in 1886. This copy has been dated to about the 8th or 9th century, C.E. The Gospel of Peter was rejected as being apocryphal by the early church, and therefore not appropriate for inclusion in the New Testament. It is most known for a reference to a “talking cross,” following the resurrection of Jesus. The Gospel of Peter is not simply a pseudonymous writing, it is specifically a forgery.

 

The Prevalence of Forgery and Pseudepigraphy in the Ancient World

There is no doubt among scholars, across the academic spectrum, that the problem of forgery existed within the early Christian movement. Forgery was a serious moral issue more broadly within the world of classical thought across the Roman Empire during the time of Jesus. Ancient authors often complained that other unscrupulous writers would write literary material in the name of another well-known person to give such work credibility and added authority. Nevertheless, we possess a variety of works from the ancient Greco-Roman world which are not regarded as forged, such as the historical writings of Suetonius and Plutarch. In some other cases, certain non-Christian pseudepigraphical works have survived which lack a definitive negative moral taint to them, despite disputes about their authorship.

For example, Aristophanes wrote his early plays under the names of the persons who directed his plays. Xenophon’s Anabasis was written in the third person, a kind of pseudepigraphic writing style, which most scholars today still attribute to the ancient Greek soldier and writer Xenophon. Even Bart Ehrman acknowledges cases where there were concerns to “protect the identity of the real author, in cases in which the safety or other personal concerns were an issue,” such as with the 5th century C.E. Archbishop Nestorius writing in the name of Heraclides in his Liber Heraclidis.9

Within the early Christian movement in particular, we face a similar situation. Numerous writings were clearly forged in the name of well-known Christian figures. Such works include:

  • The Gospel of Thomas
  • The Gospel of James
  • The Gospel of Philip
  • The Gospel of Peter
  • Third Corinthians
  • Paul’s Letter to the Laodiceans
  • The Apocalypse of Peter
  • The Apocalypse of Paul

All of the above writings among certain early Christian readers were assumed to be authentic at various times. However, in each case, the collective mind of the early church ultimately dismissed each one of these documents as forgeries, and therefore, ineligible to be included within the New Testament canon.

This did not mean that all Christians stopped reading such books once the canon was firmly established. As late as the 17th century, some Quakers adopted Paul’s Letter to the Laodiceans and considered that forged document to be on par with the rest of the New Testament. But for all practical purposes, the current list of 27 books of the New Testament remains the standard canon for all historically orthodox Christians.

What were the motivations behind such forgeries? In some cases, an over enthusiastic curiosity to explore unexplained events within the New Testament led to such writings. In other cases, a famous person’s name was used to write a polemical message, leveraging the authority of an apostle to spread a different teaching. Other writings could have been written with the possible intent to express an apostle’s teaching for a new generation of readers, and yet the forgeries were written so long after the death of the apostle that it would have been impossible to securely establish a valid reason for the pseudonymity.

Bart Ehrman’s view in Forgery and Counterforgery is that:

“in every instance of forgery that I discuss, the intention of the forger was to deceive his readers into thinking he was someone other than who he was; his motivation was not only to receive a simple hearing of his views (although certainly that) but also to authorize his views through the authority provided by the status of his falsely assumed authorial name. His goal was to advance his own polemical agenda” (p. 153).

 

The Progressive Christian Attempt to Justify Forgery in the New Testament Without Calling it “Forgery”

Therefore, when it comes to the books that actually made it into our New Testament, the charge of forgery is quite serious, and yet some progressive Christian scholars do not seem too bothered by this.  A number of progressive Christian scholars today will argue that having the presence of certain dubious pseudonymous works in our New Testament is not problematic for our New Testament canon.  They would argue that while such works are indeed pseudepigraphy, using the name of a well-known Christian authority in a deliberate attempt to change the teachings of that authoritative person, they would hesitate to use the terminology of “forgery” to apply in such a situation.

Such logic is fallacious. This is one area where conservative Christian scholars can agree with a skeptic like Bart Ehrman. Ehrman convincingly demonstrates that in the classical world, a lie was considered as a lie, and the same type of logic applied to the thinking of the early church. As theologian Michael Kruger states in his review of Ehrman’s work,

“It is fashionable today to suggest a ‘middle way’ where the pseudonymity of some NT books is affirmed and the canonicity of those books is also affirmed. However, Ehrman is absolutely correct that early Christians simply did not see it this way. To them, forgery was a lie, plain and simple. “10

There are legitimate reasons in certain cases, which we will cover in future blog posts, where a genuinely authentic, non-forged New Testament work might still have some characteristics of pseudonymity. However, it can be fairly stated that if someone tried to produce a New Testament writing that sought to twist and distort the teaching of someone like Paul, in an effort to deceive the reading audience, it should indeed be considered as a forgery. If that is the case, it would be better to be honest about the failure of the New Testament canonization of Scripture process.

However, as this review will attempt to do in subsequent blog posts, there is sufficient evidence to demonstrate the integrity of the New Testament canon. We can still have confidence that every book of the New Testament is truly the Word of God and not a forgery. But a careful examination of the evidence is required to substantiate the argument.

See you in the next installment of this multi-blog-post book review of Bart Ehrman’s Forgery and Counterforgery.

 

Notes:

1. See Michael Kruger’s “Canon Fodder” blog.   ↩

2. Ferdinand Christian Baur (F.C. Baur) took an even more radical view of the New Testament, particularly that of Paul’s letters. Baur’s research suggested that “only the Epistles to the Galatians, Corinthians, and Romans can be confidently used as sources” for Paul’s theology (Albert Schweitzer, Paul and His Interpreters: A Critical History, p. 14). “Baur had distinguished three classes of Epistles. In the first he placed, as beyond doubt genuine, Galatians, [1 & 2] Corinthians, and Romans; Ephesians, Colossians, Philippians, Thessalonians, and Philemon formed the second class, being considered uncertain; the Pastoral Epistles formed the third class, and were regarded as proved to be spurious.” (Schweitzer, p. 25). While the so-called Tübingen school which Baur was associated with has been superseded in the academia, more refined critical views, like that of Bart Ehrman, continue to dominate secular academia. See this discussion on progressive Christianity.  For more on the history and role of “historical criticism” in the study of the Bible, see this Veracity blog series.  ↩

3. See extended video discussion about the Walter Bauer thesis. ↩

4. Forgery and Counterforgery, Bart Ehrman. p.29ff. Further citations will be in the text as “Ehrman.” ↩

5. See D. A. Carson, “Pseudonymity and Pseudepigraphy,” ed. Craig A. Evans and Stanley E. Porter, Dictionary of New Testament Background: A Compendium of Contemporary Biblical Scholarship, as quoted in Michael Heiser, Reversing Hermon: Enoch, the Watchers, and the Forgotten Mission of Jesus Christ, p. 13 ↩

6. See Michael Heiser, Reversing Hermon. p. 13. See also Heiser’s blog post on “Lying and Deception.” ↩

7. See Michael Heiser, Reversing Hermon. p. 216ff. See blog post on head coverings. ↩

8. See Ben Witherington, Letters and Homilies for Hellenized Christians: A Socio-Rhetorical Commentary on Titus, 1-2 Timothy and 1-3 John, p. 26 ↩

9. Ehrman, Forgery and Counterforgery. p. 46-47. In the case of Xenophon’s Anabasis, Ehrman holds the judgment that Plutarch did as well, that this style of writing was “not innocent at all.” But does this mean that Xenophon’s work should be thoroughly discredited? Few historians would agree with that. As to the notion of protecting the identity of the real author, a case could be made this might be why the Book of Hebrews contains no acknowledgement of the author’s name, as various scholars contend that Hebrews was written during a time of persecution. It is reasonable then to assert that the lack of naming the author of Hebrews was done intentionally, in an effort to protect the identity of the author and/or the Christian community or communities such as author was hoping to encourage in a time of persecution. ↩

10. See Michael Kruger’s review of Forged in the Themelios journal. The work of progressive Christian scholar John Barton is an illustrative example of how an attempt is made to say that some unknown writer ascribed the name of Paul to certain letters, in an effort to domesticate or substantially change the message of the great apostle, and yet still suggest that the inclusion of such a work in the New Testament may be of no great consequence, at least among some Christians. “The Pastorals [1 Timothy, 2 Timothy, Titus] have no place in attempting to reconstruct the thought of Paul, but there is nothing to prevent our studying the thought of the Pastorals, and finding it interesting and perhaps persuasive……Are Paul’s letters authoritative because they are by Paul? If so, then establishing that one of them is in fact pseudonymous presumably reduces or even annuls its authority. Or are they authoritative because they are in the Bible? If so, the question of who wrote them might be regarded as irrelevant. For most Christians, the answer is probably a blend of both factors, though this is arguably incoherent.” To be “arguably incoherent” on this latter point is an understatement here. Contra Barton, if the early church truly erred in falsely ascribing a New Testament document as being authentic, this would only bring great shame upon the Christian movement. John Barton, A History of the Bible: The Book and Its Faiths, p. 186-187. See Veracity book review for more details. ↩


What Andy Stanley Gets Right…. and Wrong… About The LGBTQ+ Conversation

The Internet is all abuzz about a recent conference at Andy Stanley’s North Point Community Church in Atlanta geared to help parents of LGBTQ+ children navigate through their struggles. Certain conservative Christian leaders, like Southern Baptist Seminary President, Al Mohler, have decried the conference, suggesting that Andy Stanley has parted ways from historic orthodox Christianity. Alternatively, certain progressive Christians have spoken out somewhat in favor of Andy Stanley here, while also indicating that not enough was shown regarding what they see as the moral bankruptcy of continuing to restrict the definition of marriage as being only between one man and one woman for one life.

How does an evangelical Christian respond to all of this?  In defending the Unconditional Conference sponsored by Embracing the Journey, Andy Stanley has got some things right, while also getting some other things wrong.

Megachurch pastor Andy Stanley. Promoter of Biblical truth… or compromiser?

 

What Andy Stanley Gets Right

First, let us consider what Andy Stanley got right. Aside from the confusion experienced by many young people themselves today questioning their sexual and gender identity, the trauma that many Christian parents of such children face, trying to figure out how best to respond and love their children, can be extremely difficult and bewildering. Aside from a few pockets here and there, a long history of full-blown hatred against LGBTQ+ persons is finally starting to disappear, but there are still problems with the emerging, hopefully more-compassionate, less-combative approaches.

Unfortunately, there seems to be two paths currently taken in certain evangelical circles these days. One path might best be called the “stick your head in the sand” approach. Many such Christians simply want the LGBTQ+ discussion to go away. But that simply will not do. The data is not fully in yet, but some suggest that as many as one out of four young people today, growing up in the age of social media, wrestle with either a sense of sexual attraction to the same sex, or experience a sense of discomfort or anxiety about their own gender identity. Do the math. At least one out of five, but perhaps even one out of four. The sheer numbers are staggering. The LGBTQ+ discussion is not going away anytime soon.

The other path is to at first write into a church’s statement of faith or covenant a commitment for membership to only support traditional marriage, between one man and one woman. While this honorable stand for 2000 years of church teaching is taken, the church then sadly provides very little in terms of helping young people work through these questions of sexual and gender identity, as well as not providing sufficient resources for parents and other family members of such young people to work through their questions and struggles.

In this sense, Andy Stanley was right to break out of both the “stick your head in the sand” approach as well as the purely moral posturing approach, which offers little to no practical help. Andy Stanley was right to sponsor a conference intended to offer pastoral help and assistance for parents who want to know what to do when their son or daughter does not know if they are a “son” or a “daughter,” or if their son or daughter finds themselves attracted to members of the same sex. Parents need a safe space where they can share their stories, and listen and learn from one another, so that they can better know how to support their children.

According to a Sean McDowell video posted below, Alan Shlemon of Stand to Reason attended the conference and reported that some of the sessions were very helpful in creating that kind of safe space, which is so desperately needed today. Thankfully, there are more and more resources available today that can help parents be equipped to better deal with these issues in their parenting. One that I can recommend is the Center for Faith, Sexuality and Gender. I was able to convince just a few of the staff at my church to attend such a training event a few years ago. I wish I could have gotten a few more to attend, but a few is much better than nothing!

Andy Stanley’s most knee-jerk critics should keep these positive points in mind before piling on against Andy.

What Andy Stanley Gets Wrong

On the other hand, there are some other things that Andy Stanley got wrong. I will note one thing in particular. Some of the speakers at the Embrace the Journey conference affirm a traditional, historically orthodox view of marriage and gender identity. That is great. However, not all of the speakers do so.

According to Shlemon, two of the speakers were gay men already participating in what is commonly known today as same-sex marriages. While there was no overt attempt to try to argue against a traditional view of marriage by the speakers, promotional material written by such speakers at the conference was made available to participants, seeking to challenge the traditional view of marriage.

For example, one of the other speakers was David Gushee, a scholar in Christian ethics. I never knew or met Dr. Gushee, but I know of friends who knew him. While I was off-to-college out of town in the 1980’s, David Gushee attended the College of William and Mary in my home town, where he participated in the evangelical Christian community. David Gushee even served as the youth director at a conservative evangelical Baptist church in Williamsburg, where my Boy Scout troop met when I was a kid. After college, David Gushee pursued Christian ministry and scholarship, but he eventually completely changed his mind regarding the biblical definition of marriage, publishing a book chronicling his change of thinking in 2014, which received a lot of media attention.  It boggles my mind how a young college student in my hometown went onto become a nationally-known, influential figure. But there you go.

I actually agree with Dr. Gushee when he supports those same-sex attracted believers who have been mistreated by Christian institutions, when someone holds to a traditional sexual ethic, while still acknowledging their same-sex attraction. Such idiotic treatment of fellow Christians completely baffles me. But Dr. Gushee goes much further than that with his perspective contrary to historic Christian teachings.

Again, according to Shlemon, Dr. Gushee did not openly try to persuade the conference participants to adopt his point of view. But apparently his books were there…. and it only takes a few clicks on the Internet to find out what Dr. Gushee really thinks.

In a Sunday sermon, Andy Stanley offered a response to critics, noting that North Point Community Church still teaches an historic view of marriage as being between one man and one woman, while still defending hosting the Embracing the Journey conference. As he put it, the Embracing the Journey conference was not a theology conference. Rather, it was a pastoral conference.

Here is the problem which Andy Stanley faces. On the one hand, theologically, Andy Stanley appears to be saying that his church still affirms an historic orthodox view of Christian marriage in its teaching. So far, so good. At the same time, the church is hosting a conference where several of the speakers hold a position on marriage which is out of step with the official position of the church. This is confusing.

Was North Point Community Church offering a conference where the speakers were being “platformed” by the church? Or was the conference simply an invitation to “have a conversation?”

I am all for the idea of dialogue. I am all in support of having conversations with people with whom I disagree. Churches should not be afraid to sponsor such conversations. But there is a huge difference between “having a conversation” and actually giving a platform for a speaker, who holds views which are contrary to the teaching of the church. Even if the speaker is not expressing their contrary views at such a speaking event, it really lacks a sense of clarity and transparency as to what the purpose of the event actually is. The outrage over the Embracing the Journey conference, given such lack of clarity and transparency, is not surprising. It might prove to be very difficult for Andy Stanley to recover from this situation.

Where were the elders of North Point Community Church when the decision was made to host the Embracing the Journey conference? Did they know if they were simply sponsoring an event, “having the conversation?” Or did they know that they might be platforming controversial speakers, who have publicly let the world know that they hold theological positions which go against the teaching of the church?

Chances are, even if Andy Stanley and the elders of North Point had effectively communicated beforehand that the conference was a only a conversation with contrary voices, and not a platforming event, Andy Stanley would probably still have his critics. There is not much you can do about that.  However, when churches like North Point fail to follow sound-principles of discernment they only generate a sense of mistrust of their leaders.

The irony of all of this is that Andy Stanley is known for hosting a Leadership podcast. Well, with all due respect, the way the Embracing the Journey conference was handled was not good leadership.

Andy Stanley means well, but this is one specific area where Andy Stanley got things wrong.

Grace and Truth in the LGBTQ+ Conversation

Not all Christian leaders who hold to an historic, orthodox Christian sexual ethic offer the same type of assistance to Christian parents. Voices ranging from Rosaria Butterfield and Christopher Yuan to Gregory Coles and Wesley Hill handle the pastoral issues quite differently, but they all recognize the consistent witness of Scripture regarding the definition of marriage held throughout the centuries. I lean towards approaches advocated by authors like the latter Gregory Coles and Wesley Hill, as the former voices tend to view “same-sex orientation” as some type of modern myth, which is hard to comprehend why they see the issue that way. Nevertheless, regardless of the approach, it is important that churches handle LGBTQ+ concerns with both grace and truth. The controversy at Andy Stanley’s church is not the first time confusion like this has shaken Christians. Nor will it probably be the last. Nevertheless, we can do better.

Andy Stanley is a high-profile Christian leader in evangelicalism, pastoring one of the largest churches in the United States.  He is basically a household name in evangelial Christianity. If local churches can follow the positive trend set by Andy Stanley, to offer better resources to parents wrestling with LGBTQ+ concerns in their family, then this would be a very good demonstration of grace. However, there is a negative side. For if local churches do not sufficiently uphold truth with clarity, then more confusion will inevitably result, with the unintended consequence of making grace less accessible, to where it is needed most.

Discerning the nature of the conference is crucial; that is, was this an invitation to “have a conversation,” or was it a platforming event offering an implicit endorsement of views contrary to North Point’s stated position? Many have already concluded that this was a platforming event, and I can understand why. Many have already written off Andy Stanley as a false teacher.

I do wish more churches would provide conferences and support for parents of LGBTQ+ as North Point has tried to do. But sadly the confusion over the nature of the conference, and even some points raised by Andy towards the end of his sermon, will potentially discourage families who need help the most to avoid churches that are trying ways to stay true to Scripture while simultaneously creating those safe places for sharing deep personal struggles. Church leaders need to communicate clearly when they are platforming a speaker, and by association, the message they stand for, versus hosting a conversational dialogue with those who do not subscribe to the teachings aligned with that church. I have seen this scenario of confusion played out in other contexts that need not be discussed here.

Have a listen to the Sean McDowell and Alan Shlemon discussion, as well as Andy Stanley’s sermon, and decide for yourself what Andy Stanley got right, and got wrong.

 

For other Veracity blog posts on this topic see: 


The Myth of the Myth of Christian Persecution: Wolfram Kinzig on Early Christian Martyrdom

When my wife and I visited Rome in 2018, we had the opportunity to visit the famed Colosseum. In my mind I beheld images of Christians cowering in the corner, as the lions were being released, while Rome’s pagan citizenry cheered on Emperor Nero’s animals to destroy those who confessed the name of Jesus. Though a gruesome thought, it is still a sobering and inspiring demonstration of the resiliency of Christian faith.

It was quite a shock then to hear our docent tell us that we have no evidence of Christians being ripped apart by lions at the Colosseum under the reign of Nero. Nero died in the year 68 A.D., and construction of the Colosseum did not begin until 70 A.D. when Vespasian became emperor. The structure was not completed until 80 A.D.

I guess I really did not know my history as well as I thought I did….

The Colosseum of Rome. In our trip to Rome in 2018, my wife and I learned that contrary to popular belief, Christians were not “fed to the lions” simply because of their faith here. Instead, the story is more complicated.

Continue reading


Lies My Preacher Told Me, by Brent Strawn: A Short(er) Review

Have you ever been told that if you are reading the Old Testament you are reading someone else’s mail? If that preacher also tells you that instead the New Testament was mail written to you, then this is a lie your preacher has told you.

While much of the Old Testament was written to ancient Israelites, some of Paul’s letters were written to first century Corinthians. Greco-Roman Corinth culture is far away from the 21st century, says Old Testament scholar Brent Strawn. When we read anything in the Bible, yes, we are reading someone else’s mail, written to people in ancient times, but that same correspondence was also written for us today as Christians.

The fact is that the very issues we run into while reading the New Testament are also present when we read the Old Testament. But not only that, the New Testament is constantly recalling the message of the Old Testament. For without a good understanding of the Old Testament, the message of the New Testament becomes hard to grasp. That is a good argument for not ignoring the Old Testament.

Taking a More Honest Look at the Old Testament

Brent Strawn teaches the Old Testament at Duke Divinity School, and in Lies My Preacher Told Me: An Honest Look at the Old Testament, the author is spinning off from the well-known title by James W. Loewen, Lies My Teacher Told Me: Everything Your American History Textbook Got Wrong. It is a bit of a click-bait title, as Dr. Strawn admits that he has had some wonderful Bible teachers and preachers in his own life. But we as Christians can all use some correction now and then in making changes to bad reading habits of the Bible.

Lies My Preacher Told Me is written in the style of similar short books written by scholars writing for a general public audience, like Dr. Michael Heiser’s 60 Second Scholar series, or the Urban Legends series, pioneered by David A. Croteau, among other scholars in that series. In Dr. Strawn’s short and concise book, he outlines ten mistruths that are in need of correction:

  • Mistruth 1: The Old Testament is “someone else’s mail.”
  • Mistruth 2: The Old Testament is a boring history book.
  • Mistruth 3: The Old Testament has been rendered permanently obsolete.
  • Mistruth 4: The Old Testament God is mean . . . really mean.
  • Mistruth 5: The Old Testament is hyper-violent.
  • Mistruth 6: David wrote the Psalms [and other simplistic historical assertions]
  • Mistruth 7: The Old Testament isn’t spiritually enriching.
  • Mistruth 8: The Old Testament isn’t practically relevant.
  • Mistruth 9: The Old Testament Law is nothing but a burden, impossible to keep.
  • Mistruth 10: What really matters is that “everything is about Jesus.”

Those of you familiar with the Veracity blog will know that I am very much excited about the work of the Cambridge House, a Christian study-center within walking distance of the College of William and Mary. Several students, faculty and friends of Cambridge House were privileged to have Dr. Strawn give a fine lecture telling the story about his book in the spring of 2023. The Cambridge House is committed to contributing a Christian voice into the intellectual conversation at the university where I work, so it is great to have such an accomplished scholar share his wisdom rooted in the Christian faith.

Brent Strawn is not just an author of a short pithy book like Lies My Preacher Told Me. He is also a well-respected Bible translator, most significantly the editor of the Old Testament portion of the Common English Bible.

Dr. Strawn has done a great service to the church for exposing and correcting these ten mistruths. Nuggets of truth are sprinkled throughout Lies My Preacher Told Me.

How about this one on page 23?: Whenever I have read Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount, Jesus goes through a series of “you have heard it said, but now I tell you this...” sayings. For years I thought that all of them, such as “love your neighbor,” were all in our Old Testament. But the second half of that one found in Matthew 5:43, “hate your enemies,” simply is not found in the Old Testament.

Shocker of shockers!! So, where did this “hate your enemies” come from? It actually comes from the Community Rule of the Dead Sea Scrolls, 1QS 9.21, to be more precise, which endorses hating those who are wicked. Did the Jewish community at Qumran subscribe to the idea that this Community Rule was also part of Sacred Scripture? This little nugget suggests that the definition of what constituted Jewish “Scripture” among some Jewish groups in Jesus’ day was perhaps slightly broader than what we have in our Old Testament today.

Though hidden in one of the very few footnotes in the book, Dr. Strawn succinctly handles a rather difficult question regarding the nature of the Old Testament canon of Scripture.  Many Christians often assume that the list of books included in our Old Testament today was well settled by the time of Jesus. Not so. It took another century or more after the days of Jesus before the Jewish community finally settled on a definitive list of books to be included in their Hebrew Scriptures, a listing that eventually was picked up and settled upon by the Protestant movement, in the 16th century. However, if this makes someone nervous, it is abundantly clear that the books of our Old Testament today were all composed before the time of Jesus, and enjoyed their authoritative status in Jesus’ day.

In mistruth #9, Dr. Strawn tackles the common misperception that for the Jews the Old Testament Law was impossible to keep, which is why Christianity teaches a message of grace, as opposed to the Jewish message of salvation by works. However, the Apostle Paul tells us in Philippians 3:4-6 that prior to being a Christian, as a Pharisee he was “blameless” under the Law.

“Blameless?” How could Paul say that if indeed the Law was impossible to keep? Rather, it is Jesus, in the Sermon on the Mount, who insists that no one can enter God’s Kingdom without exceeding the righteousness of the scribes and Pharisees.  Jesus himself sets the higher standard, thereby exposing everyone’s need for grace, Jew and Gentile.

In the final mistruth, Dr. Strawn gives a more modest and accurate estimate of what constitutes Old Testament prophecy concerning the coming of Jesus. A number of Christian apologists tend to over-inflate claims about how much the Old Testament predicts the coming of Jesus as the Messiah. So while certain Old Testament texts could be read in a way such that we can find somewhere around “300” to even “400” Old Testament prophecies being fulfilled in the New Testament by Jesus, Dr. Strawn estimates that the number should be more modestly put at around thirty-nine. Though not zero, 39 is significantly less than 300 or 400.

But why only about 39? Why not 300 or 400? Well, a lot of the mismatch has to do with how Christians believe a prophecy is being fulfilled in Jesus. It turns out that the interpretation of prophecy is generally more complicated than that depicted by popular thinking.

Having worked previously with a Jewish colleague for a number of years, I have come to realize that while a strong case can still be made for predicting the coming of Jesus from the Old Testament, overzealous attempts to read Jesus almost anywhere into the Old Testament can backfire when conversing with a Jewish person well-informed about their Hebrew Scriptures. A modest defense for the Christian faith is far more effective than making extravagant claims which can be easily shot down by a non-believer better informed than we are.

One Pushback For Lies My Preacher Told Me

Alas, if I had but one pushback against Lies My Preacher Told Me, it would be this: Brent Strawn makes plentiful use of the Common English Bible when quoting from Scripture in his book, page after page, which is both good and not so good.The “not so good” might limit the outreach capability of Dr. Strawn’s book. I hesitate to pick on an esteemed scholar who has poured himself so much into a bible translation. It feels like telling someone that their baby is both cute and ugly at the same time. Yikes. I do not mean to do that so I hope this comes across in the right way.

First, the good: The Common English Bible (CEB) is quite a fine translation in that it offers a very accessible level of reading without becoming too loose, as paraphrases tend to be. Something like Eugene Peterson’s The Message is very readable, but the Common English Bible (CEB) is just as readable as The Message, if not more so, but the CEB stays much closer to the actual Scriptural text. I think of the CEB as the “entry level” version to the more academic New Revised Standard Version (NRSV) of the Bible. Nerdy Bible geeks like me generally like the NRSV, but busy soccer moms on the go will find the CEB more suitable. I like reading the CEB when desiring to tackle longer portions of the text, and I value its freshness and willingness to break out of a traditional mold.

Read Ezekiel 23:20 if you want a good jolt…. Just do not read it with your small children present….

….Trust me on this one.

On the downside, the Common English Bible (CEB) is marketed more towards mainline Protestant churches and less towards conservative evangelical, Roman Catholic, and Eastern Orthodox churches. So while a number of evangelical scholars like Brent Strawn contributed to the making of the CEB, the main publishing houses for the Common English Bible are associated with the Disciples of Christ, the Presbyterian Church U.S.A., the Episcopal Church, the United Church Christ, and the United Methodist Church, which are perhaps the most theologically liberal denominations in America today. As noted in a recent “Ready to Harvest” YouTube video, the Pew Center reports that these mainline Protestant churches sadly are heading towards a speedy decline over the next few decades. Miracles can still happen, but it is unlikely that the CEB will have the widest reach when its primary reading audience gets smaller and smaller every year.

Furthermore, in an effort to make the text more readable there are times when the CEB over-interprets the text in ways that can obscure rather than clarify. For example, the CEB likes to use the terminology of “the Human One” when giving an alternative to the more traditional “the Son of Man,”  the former which seems a little gender-inclusively clunky.

Lastly, while a conservative evangelical translation like the English Standard Version (ESV) has been faulted for favoring more traditional, complementarian readings of the original text, regarding the role of women in the church and in the family, the CEB tends to do just the opposite, leaning towards egalitarian readings of the original text. The CEB may very well be correct, in the final analysis, regarding certain translation decisions, but for critics who say that the ESV tends to be tribalistic, the same could also be said for the CEB, but in another direction.

Towards a Better Way of Reading and Appreciating the Old Testament

But do not let this one pushback dissuade the reader from picking up a copy of Lies My Preacher Told Me. The chapters are short but the content found therein is rich with golden nuggets that can nourish the reader and get them excited about the Old Testament.

The second century heterodox preacher in Rome, Marcion, will forever be associated with the sometimes unfortunate Christian dislike, or even hatred, of the Old Testament. Marcion is known to be the first churchman to draft a list of what he considered to be canonical Scripture for Christians, and yet he conveniently scratched the entire Old Testament off of his list. For Marcion, the Old Testament God was not the God of the New Testament. That made his Bible significantly shorter, but the historically orthodox Christian community believed that Marcion stripped out the riches of the Old Testament, thus emasculating the Bible as a whole. Marcion was rightly condemned for his heresy. Be ye aware, there are Marcions still lurking around in many corners of the church today.

Brent Strawn is committed to encouraging the revived use of the Old Testament among Christians. Lies My Preacher Told Me serves as a pithy, clear, and helpful resource for promoting an increase of interest in the Old Testament, something Marcion would surely have hated.

I suggested to Brent that he should have a portrait of Marcion in his home, and use it as a dart board. Perhaps he will make a meme out of that, and we might find it in his next book. We shall see!

.

For the “real” Bible nerds, you might be interested in the following interview with Dr. Brent Strawn. Enjoy.


Why “Red Letter” Christianity Short-Changes the Full Story of the Gospel

“Well done, good and faithful slave.”

How would you like that to read on your tombstone? Most Bible translations of this verse, Matthew 25:21, read “good and faithful servant,” or something less provocative. The Legacy Standard Bible is one of the few translations today that reads “good and faithful slave.”

“Slave??? Jesus said that?”

Skeptics will confront me to say that the New Testament condones slavery. How do I respond? Well, on this particular point, with respect to Matthew 25:21, the skeptics have a valid point to make. But this needs a bit more unpacking to explain, as the complaint from skeptics is misleading.

Frederick Douglass, born February, 1818, into slavery. Photo colorization by Marina Amarai. Many associate “slavery” as found in the Bible with what Frederick Douglass experienced in early 19th century America. The story of “slavery” in the Bible, like other issues with respect to social justice (and other aspects of the problem of evil), is more complicated than what many Christians and skeptics typically think.

 

“Red-Letter” Christianity??

There is a movement among many Christians called “Red-Letter Christianity.” As explained from a previous Veracity blog post, the idea arose from the fact that just over a hundred years ago, some Bible publishers began to print the words spoken by Jesus in red, to distinguish the sayings of Jesus from the rest of the New Testament text. The venerable King James Version (KJV) of the Bible contains no quotation marks, so it is difficult to discern when someone is speaking and when an author is simply giving narration. Yet despite its problems, having the words of Jesus highlighted in red has been helpful to many over the past decades.

Efforts like “Red-Letter Christianity” can be well-intended, seeking to soften the edge of a lot of supposedly Christian rhetoric these days deemed to be harmful to others. A lot of times, the way we express the truths found in the Bible matters just as much, sometimes even more, than the actual truths themselves. The Bible can be easily weaponized to hurt people, so it is understandable to a certain degree that “Red-Letter” Christianity pushes back against such misuse of Scripture.

Some who describe themselves as “Progressive Christians” would also call themselves “Red-Letter” Christians. For example, when push comes to shove, many such “Red-Letter” Christians will say that they will take the words of Jesus over the letters of Paul, or other writings in the New Testament, any day. However, such efforts that try to elevate the words of Jesus like this have their own downsides to them.

So-called “Red Letter Bibles” were probably a good idea in the beginning, but they have sure made a mess of things.

 

Noah curses his son Ham, a 19th-century painting by Ivan Stepanovitch Ksenofontov.  The so-called “Curse of Ham” in Genesis 9:25 was the foundational prooftext used to defend the institution of slavery in the ante-bellum American South. Contrary to popular opinion, Jesus never comes out to explicitly condemn slavery. This blog post seeks to explain why, and to offer a better approach to how the New Testament deals with slavery.

 

Some Potentially Embarrassing “Red Letters” of Jesus

A focus on the “Red Letter” speeches of Jesus has good intentions behind it, but a careful examination of these red letters should give us some pause. Consider the “Red Letters” of Jesus found In Revelation 2:22-23, where the writer John is retelling a vision he has of Jesus speaking out against a female false teacher in one of Revelation’s seven churches, Thyatira, who is propagating a number of bad ideas in that Christian community:

Behold, I will cast her into a bed, and them that commit adultery with her into great tribulation, except they repent of their deeds. And I will kill her children with death; and all the churches shall know that I am he which searcheth the reins and hearts: and I will give unto every one of you according to your works.

Yikes. Even with the archaic language of the KJV, this sounds pretty harsh. I can hear the objection of the skeptic now: “Well, your Jesus wants to murder children. I know that, because the words of Jesus are printed in red.”

Those red letters suddenly begin to look like red flags.

It is important to concede something here. There are a number of disturbing things Jesus says in this passage, but I highlighted the number one thing that bothers me: “And I will kill her children with death.” The ESV translation renders this phrase, “I will strike her children dead.” For this Christian who is pro-life, particularly with respect to abortion, this red-letter snippet from Jesus can be jarring. Does Jesus really want to kill a woman’s children, even if this woman is a heretic?

However, a proper understanding of the literary context of any book of the Bible is essential to interpreting the Bible responsibly. Some Christians will staunchly defend the idea that they take the Bible “literally,” without a careful examination of what “literally” even means. Instead, it is better to consider what is the literary genre of a book like Revelation. The Book of Revelation falls within the peculiar genre of apocalypticism, a group of writings that grew out of Judaism that are heavily laced with hyperbole and metaphor. The Book of Daniel in the Old Testament is another example of apocalyptic literature, where parts of Daniel have a very similar feel to what is read in Revelation.

It can be well argued that Jesus is not hyper-literally favoring abortion or infanticide here, but rather is condemning the bad fruit of the false teaching associated with this “Jezebel” from Thyratia.  In other words, this reference to “Jezebel’s” children metaphorically symbolizes the corruptive result of this woman’s incorrect doctrine, which distorts the truth, a distortion which Jesus intends to do away with.

Oh, and lest we forget, more than anyone else in the entire New Testament, Jesus speaks about the doctrine of hell the most. Depending on the Bible translation, the word “hell” appears anywhere from 13 to 23 times in the New Testament, the majority traced back to the lips of Jesus, even in the Book of Revelation. In comparison, the letters of Paul barely mention “hell” at all. The concept of eternal lostness, one of the most despised concepts of Christianity in our contemporary world, is found primarily in the “Red Letter” words of Jesus.

Yes, the “Red Letter” Jesus does speak about love, goodness, and kindness towards others. But that same “Red Letter” Jesus also speaks words of judgment against a hard-hearted and disobedient people.

Chapel Mural

In the Gospels, Jesus calls all of the little children to come unto him and loved them (Mark 10:13-16). But in Revelation 2:22-23, Jesus threatens to “kill the children” of a woman described as a false teacher in the church. A more responsible reading of the so-called “Red Letters” of Jesus is needed that values the original literary context of the New Testament. (From a mural painted at the Williamsburg Community Chapel).

 

Smoothing Over Some the “Red Letters” of Jesus?

In comparison to the Book of Revelation, the Gospels are quite a different form of biblical literature.Yet even in the Gospels, Jesus used hyperbole and metaphor rather frequently. Just think about Jesus’ instruction to “hate” your own family (Luke 14:26). However, there is a tendency to try to smooth over some of those “Red Letters” of Jesus which make us feel even more uncomfortable.

Philip Jenkins, an historian at Baylor University whose work I have reviewed a few times on this blog, has written a very insightful article about Matthew 25:21. As Jenkins informs us, the problem is that we often read parts of the Bible through our own cultural lens, and when it comes to “slavery,” the experience of racial-based, chattel slavery in American history immediately comes to mind. But the “slavery” during the New Testament period was different. The Romans never paid any attention to skin color when it came to slavery. If your cultural group was defeated by the Roman army, then your group became perfect candidates for Roman enslavement in an effort to make reparations for war debts, regardless of the pigment of one’s skin. But nevertheless, slavery is slavery.

To be a slave in Jesus’ day was to be considered a piece of property in the eyes of the master. Furthermore, in the world of the first century Roman Empire, slavery was a big deal, and the Roman province of Israel was no exception. Historians estimate that roughly one out for three persons living in the Roman Empire in the time of Jesus was a slave.

People looking to “Red Letter” Christianity to find a message from Jesus condemning slavery will be hard pressed. The Legacy Standard Bible, a translation produced by the seminary founded by John MacArthur, a pastor in Southern California, uses the English word “slave” for the Greek “doulos.” Some translations will use the word “bondservant” or “servant,” to try to convey the same idea.

These translations work to a certain extent. Indentured servitude, where slaves could work off their debts to earn their freedom, commonly known as “debt bondage,” was more widely practiced in the ancient Roman empire than what you find with cradle-to-grave slavery in the antebellum American South. However, the use of  “bondservant” or “servant” may obscure the original meaning as it was originally heard by Jesus’ hearers in first century Galilee or Jerusalem. Sure, it makes me squirm a bit, but the text is still authoritative and worth considering, if you read it within the longer context of the global history of slavery. Read Jesus’ speaking in Luke 12:47-48, from the Legacy Standard Bible:

And that slave who knew his master’s will and did not get ready or act in accord with his will, will receive many beatings, but the one who did not know it, and committed deeds worthy of a beating, will receive but a few. From everyone who has been given much, much will be required, and to whom they entrusted much, of him they will ask all the more.

That comes straight from a modern equivalent of your “Red Letter” Bible, folks. However, statements like these can be balanced by other sayings made by Jesus: “You shall know the truth, and the truth shall set you free” (John 8:32). But this is speaking more of slavery in metaphorical terms, as in spiritual slavery, and not so much about physical, chattel slavery. So, what are we to think about this?1

A Better Way to Think About the New Testament’s Approach to Slavery

The reality is that the only New Testament message which challenges chattel slavery can be found in the writings of the Apostle Paul, but you will not find Paul’s letters written in red in any Bible I know about. Granted, Paul is not as explicit in condemning slavery as we would like, as he never directly challenges slavery as a system. Paul’s teaching in Ephesians thankfully went against the grain of typical Greco-Roman treatment of slaves (Ephesians 6:5-9), by calling masters to not “mistreat their slaves.” Nevertheless, slaves are still called to obey their masters, in Paul’s letters. Paul simply assumes the slavery system to be the societal norm. However, it is important to recognize neither Paul nor anyone else in the Bible refers to slavery as part of God’s created order. We get the “slavery from creation” idea from Aristotle, and not from the Bible.

Still, we see indirect evidence that Paul did not imagine slavery to be part of God’s ultimate plans and purposes. In 1 Corinthians 7:21, Paul encourages Christians who are slaves to pursue their freedom from slavery, if they have the opportunity. In Philemon 1:8-16, Paul considers the runaway slave, Onesimus, to be like a son and a brother, and encourages Philemon, the slave owner of Onesimus, to do the same. To call a slave a “son” or “brother” would have been revolutionary in the Greco-Roman culture, which saw slaves as merely being pieces of property.

One other example can be added to the list, though it is controversial among some scholars. In 1 Timothy 1:9-10, the KJV reads Paul as condemning “men-stealing.” Here is how the English Standard Version renders the passage:2

…the law is not laid down for the just but for the lawless and disobedient, for the ungodly and sinners, for the unholy and profane, for those who strike their fathers and mothers, for murderers,the sexually immoral, men who practice homosexuality, enslavers, liars, perjurers, and whatever else is contrary to sound doctrine…..

The ESV reads “enslavers” instead of the KJV’s “men-stealers,” but the ESV includes a helpful note describing “enslavers” as “those who take someone captive in order to sell him into slavery.” Other translations render this Greek word as “kidnappers,” which pretty well describes a lot that has gone along in the history of slavery for how slaves had been obtained in the first place, such as from the African slave trade during the American colonial era. It would be too much to call the Apostle Paul a full-on “abolitionist,” but you have to be blind to these verses to claim that Paul was a sold-out apologist for slavery.

All this being said, Paul is our best resource in the New Testament for pinpointing the evils of slavery. You just do not find such a resource in the so-called “Red Letter” words of Jesus. Those “Red Letters” do not go far enough.

That is right. We have to look to Paul, that man who is often described as supposedly “gay-hating,” “woman-hating,” etc., in order to build a Christian theology that works to address the evils of something as bad and as unjust as slavery. Jesus as presented in the so-called “Red Letters” of the Gospels and Book of Revelation does not help us much at all. Thankfully, Jesus did designate Paul to be the apostle to the Gentiles, and Jesus’ advocate for a more just and equitable world (See Galatians 1:11-12). It was this Gospel message that Paul preached throughout the Roman empire that ended up changing the world, and handing down the ethics of the New Testament over multiple generations to our present day some 20 centuries later, despite efforts in recent decades to overturn certain elements of New Testament ethics.

Christians are called to try to correct injustices in society, to work towards caring more about the environment, to fight against racism, and to advocate for the poor and needy. But we need the  whole story of the New Testament to do that, and not just the “Red Letters” of Jesus.

So-called “Red Letter” Bibles that seek to highlight the spoken words of Jesus in red were probably a good idea a century ago. But today, such Bibles can often cause more problems than what they try to solve.

 

The “Red Letters” of Jesus vs. the More Emancipating Letters of Paul, Regarding Women… and Gentiles

Here is another point: An exclusive focus on the words of Jesus are not always as helpful when it comes to concerns about women, as compared to Paul. While Jesus’ primary financial supporters were wealthy women like Mary Magdalene, Johanna, and Susanna (Luke 8:2-3), his inside top-ministry team of twelve were all men. Some argue that Jesus was simply “accommodating to a patriarchal culture” in limiting the roles of women in leadership. I have often made this type of argument in the past myself!

However, this is difficult to square with the revolutionary attacks Jesus made against Jewish cultural standards. Why would Jesus be so timid in encouraging women to be his top leaders, when he went smack dab up against the standard Jewish practice of strict Sabbath observance and in challenging the very Temple establishment itself? This idea that Jesus did not want to “upset the apple cart” of first century Judaism regarding the role of women, or that Jesus was some kind of “closet feminist,” may sound appealing to some, but it lacks solid evidence. Whatever Jesus’ motivation was, feminism was not on his highest agenda list.

Some may fault Paul for not having women serve as elders/overseers in his churches (a much disputed teaching today: read this in-depth Veracity blog series), while others support more historically-grounded, traditional readings of Paul on this issue as being still applicable today. However, despite the controversy regarding women serving as elders/overseers in local churches, Paul regularly worked alongside fellow women missionaries, as described in Romans 16. Euodia and Syntyche were regarded, not just as friends or supporters, but actual co-workers for the sake of the Gospel with Paul (Philippians 4:2-3). Paul recognized a woman named Nympha, who led a gathering of Christians in her home (Colossians 4:15).

Surely, Jesus had female friends in the Gospels. Yes, Jesus valued the women around him highly. Mary Magdalene has for centuries been regarded as “the apostle to the Apostles,” for being the first to proclaim the Good News of Jesus’ Resurrection.  Jesus’ mother Mary is probably one of the greatest, if not THE greatest, and most celebrated woman in all of world history. But none of these women have been described as Jesus’ “co-workers” like what we find with Paul.

A number of “Red Letter” Christians get incensed with Bible translations that say that Paul insists that an elder must be the “husband of one wife,” suggesting that only men are qualified for that job description (Titus 1:5-6 ESV). But the objection is overblown. For even though historical tradition going back to the early church controversially reserved the office of “elder/overseer” of a local church to qualified men in 1 Timothy 2:11-3:7, and certainly not all men are qualified, that same historical tradition affirmed both men and women as “deacons” (1 Timothy 3:8-13; Romans 16:1-2). Paul even instituted a special order of ministry among women, the “widows” of 1 Timothy 5:1-16. Paul evidently affirmed that both men and women are to serve as spiritual “fathers” and “mothers” in the church, respectively.

One more data point: There is nothing in the “Red Letters” of Jesus to suggest that it was possible to be a true follower of Jesus and not be circumscribed. As presented in the Gospels, Jesus was Jewish and expected those who follow him to adhere to the tenets of Judaism, including circumcision. With just a few exceptions, most of Jesus’ ministry was with his fellow Jews, and not Gentiles.

Jesus himself stated that he “was sent only to the lost sheep of the house of Israel” (Matthew 15:24 ESV). No mention of Gentiles here.

You read that right, folks. In “Red Letter” Bibles, Jesus’ focus was on his ministry towards the Jews, and not the Gentiles. Living in an age where many in America value “diversity” and “inclusion,” Jesus’ message in the Gospels can be a bit uncomfortable to accept.

Paul in prison, by Rembrandt (credit: Wikipedia). Jesus personally selected Paul to pioneer outreach to the Gentiles with the Good News of the Gospel, expanding out from Jesus’ ministry to primarily his fellow Jews.

 

Towards the Full Story of the Gospel

The story changes dramatically once we get to Paul. For years it had bothered me that Paul seemed to make a big deal about his apostolic calling to go preach the Gospel to the Gentiles. Case in point: Read 2 Corinthians 10:8…. “For even if I boast a little too much of our authority, which the Lord gave for building you up and not for destroying you, I will not be ashamed.” Paul seems to boast a lot about his apostolic calling in 2 Corinthians 10. Was Paul just being arrogant?

But I have since learned that this was not about Paul trying to make a name for himself. Rather, this was about honoring the fact that Jesus had personally selected Paul to be his representative to the Gentiles, and remove the circumcision requirement for becoming members of Christ’s family. Others who claimed to be associated with the Jesus movement rejected Paul’s message, and insisted that Gentiles must undertake circumcision in order to follow Christ. For if it was not for Paul, the expansion of Christianity would not have made it very far into the Gentile world, as the “Red Letter” message of Jesus in the Gospels had not yet paved a way for the Gentiles to enter into the covenant people of God without circumcision.

We have Paul to thank for that, in his obedience to share the Gospel the way he did with the Gentiles, as revealed to him by Jesus!

So, when I meet up with Christians who tell me that they like Jesus, but do not care much about Paul, I want to remind them of this reality: Without Paul, we simply would not have Christianity as we know it.

I am all for the idea that we should put our focus first and foremost on Jesus as believers. Of course we should. Jesus alone is our King, our Lord, and Savior. Jesus is the founder of Christianity. But if we are honest with what we read about in the New Testament, we owe a great debt to the revolutionary message given to us through Jesus’ “slave,” the Apostle Paul (see Romans 1:1). For without the story of Paul we would not have the full story of the Gospel. Jesus personally selected Paul to fulfill this vital task. Let us not short-change the Gospel by just reading the “Red Letters” of the Bible.3

Ponder this idea for a moment. Perhaps this was God’s plan all along. God probably already knew that having the Son of God walking around in human flesh in first century Israel, preaching and teaching, might be a tough sell for a people accustomed to the slavery system, despising Gentiles, etc. But after the Resurrection, things would become clearer as to what the Gospel message was all about. So it would have been fitting for Jesus to then commission Paul to spread the fullness of the Gospel message that God had intended to communicate all along.

Here is the bottom-line of this whole exercise: Too many Christians want the Bible to say things the Bible really is not saying. Skeptics of Christianity often know this, so when Christians proceed to pretend things to be true about what the Bible is saying, but the evidence points in a different direction, it only reinforces the skepticism of the skeptic (I keep having to learn this lesson the hard way myself!!).  Instead, making more modest claims about what the Bible says goes a lot farther in making a defense of the Gospel than making extraordinary, overstated claims that are very difficult to support from the evidence. When we simply allow the Bible to speak for itself, we discover things that may have never been seen before. Then these discoveries can become great opportunities to have an honest conversation with a skeptic, and wonderful things can happen.

“Red Letter Christianity” gives us truth about the Gospel. But it only gives us a partial truth. In the worst cases, it can even distort the truth. To focus only or even primarily on the “Red Letters” of Jesus undermines the full story of the Gospel. To get the full story of the New Testament faith we need the rest of the New Testament, including the story of the Apostle Paul.

 

If you appreciated this blog post, you might want to check out other Veracity articles on Christian approaches from an historically orthodox perspective to such hot topics as slavery, justice, climate change, racism, women in the church and the home, homosexuality, reaching out in love towards our LGBTQ friends, and protecting the poor and the needy. Be sure to subscribe to new blog posts via email, on the right side of the page (unfortunately, the Twitter method of following Veracity does not work well any more).

Notes:

1. Even if an appeal is made to Jesus’ statement in Luke 4:18 about him being sent “to proclaim liberty to the captives,” this is only of marginal help as the original context of where Jesus is quoting from Isaiah 61:1-2, is speaking of war captives, but not necessarily slaves.  ↩

2. Philip Jenkins does not think that the NIV’s rendering of the “men-stealing” terminology in 1 Timothy 1:10 as “slave traders” is correct. Dr. Jenkins cites a Greco-Roman source demonstrating how some forms of slave trading in the Roman empire were legal and others were not. I am not persuaded that Dr. Jenkins has it completely right that Paul is only condemning certain kinds of illegal slave trading in the Greco-Roman world, as though Paul is only listing vices that were illegal in Greco-Roman law, if I understand Dr. Jenkins correctly. To the contrary, the practice of homosexuality was legal in Greco-Roman society, and it is hard to figure out why Jenkins would include deviation from sound Christian doctrine as being against Greco-Roman law. Contrary to Dr. Jenkins, Paul is making reference to Old Testament Law when describing the list of vices to be avoided, not necessarily Greco-Roman law. Granted, you could argue that there was a legal form of acquiring slaves even in Old Testament Law in terms of making war reparations, which would not fit in the category of “slave trading,” itemized in 1 Timothy 1. But in the New Testament we have no prescriptive teaching that addresses slavery in the context of making war reparations. However, the New Testament does talk quite a bit about forgiving others, as in the Lord’s Prayer (“forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors“) . While slavery still exists today, as in the exploitation of children and the sex trade, many of the traditional motives for slavery today have been rendered moot in light of the advances in technology, particularly with farming,  and in modern complex economic systems, which mitigate against the need for traditional means of obtaining war reparations.   I also need to pushback on how Dr. Jenkins thinks through 1 Corinthians 14:34-35, as I would argue that there is a convincing argument for a better way to read this text..↩

3. This blog post complements a similar theme from a few years in another Veracity blog post.  For more on how Christians wrongly picked up the idea that slavery was somehow a part of God’s plan, see this previous Veracity blog post on that topic.  For more on how the New Testament treats women, see my book review of Andrew Bartlett’s Men and Women in Christ.  For more on the history of “Red Letter” Bibles, see this previous Veracity blog post.  ↩