Does the Bible teach that women should serve as elders in a local church?
This is a question which has become one of the most divisive issues in evangelical churches today. It is also a question filled with assumptions which begs for other questions. What is an “elder” in a local church? What is the “local church?” Then there is the question which has plagued American society culturally for at least the last ten years: What is a “woman”?
Preston Sprinkle on the Complementarian/Egalitarian Debate
My journey in exploring this question parallels much of the same journey that New Testament scholar Preston Sprinkle took, which led to him to write From Genesis to Junia: An Honest Search for What the Bible Really Says about Women in Leadership. But you may ask, “Who is Preston Sprinkle?”
Preston Sprinkle taught New Testament at Eternity Bible College, at an extension campus in Boise, Idaho, before it downsized in 2016. As a New Testament scholar, with a PhD from the University of Aberdeen (Scotland), Preston Sprinkle has written about and spoken on a number of issues relevant to the study of the New Testament. Eternity Bible College was founded by popular Christian author and speaker, Francis Chan. Francis and Preston even wrote a book together, Erasing Hell, a response to the universalism-leanings of Rob Bell, a controversial former evangelical pastor, back in 2011. After leaving Eternity Bible, Preston founded the Center for Faith, Sexuality, and Gender, providing resources for churches, parents, and other individuals, in order to more effectively care for people who struggle with questions about sexuality and gender, while upholding a traditional view of human sexuality and marriage; that is, a one-man to one-woman covenantal relationship intended for life.
As one might expect, entering any conversation regarding sexuality and gender will probably generate controversy, and Preston is no stranger to it. Preston’s previous books on these topics, such as People To Be Loved: Why Homosexuality is Not Just an Issue (reviewed here on Veracity), and Embodied: Transgender Identities, the Church, and What the Bible Has to Say (reviewed here on Veracity), have sparked very lively discussion and criticism from all sides. I have not always agreed with every element Preston puts forward in his writings, but I appreciate his willingness to tackle tough questions, doing so with a commitment to follow the Scriptural text, wherever it leads, to find answers.
Preston has been criticized by those who argue that the Christian church needs to change its stance on marriage, in order to welcome same-sex marriage, and by those who believe that one can self-identify with a certain view of gender, which is contrary to one’s biological sex. On the other side, are those Christians who believe that Preston Sprinkle coddles or even excuses sin associated with homosexuality and transgender ideology. Or Preston’s critics simply do not like the definitions of words he uses regarding certain controversial topics within the LGBTQ conversation. It would appear that some Christian leaders think it is permissible to poison the well and misrepresent what someone like Preston Sprinkle has written, and not want to sit down and talk about perceived theological differences. Preston finds his way to step on minefields, not of his own making.
What other controversy could Preston address?? Well, Preston had put off doing a deep dive into the question of “women in Christian leadership” for years, knowing that he had other scholar friends whom he highly respected, who landed on different conclusions to the question. But Preston finally took the time to read a stack of books for several years in order to write his book, as a way of bridging the gap between ordinary Christians, without seminary training, and those in the academy.
Preston’s newest book was one of my best reads of 2025 (and early 2026), having received an advanced copy of the book. Though I do feel compelled to write this rather long, critical review, as I will explain below.

Preston Sprinkle offers a rigorous exegetical examination of the complementarian versus egalitarian debate, concerning the interpretation of Scripture in From Genesis to Junia: An Honest Search for What the Bible Really Says about Women in Leadership. Preston aims well to call out balls and strikes, but he misses a few calls.




